Beneath the Surface
By Kayla Bickham
Loss of basic needs such as food, clothing and shelter are not the only contributing factors to poverty. Those in poverty can experience mental disadvantages as well. Although money can contribute to loss of food or clothing, it does not do much when it comes to social or psychological factors.
According to the American Economic Review in 2016, everyone relies on a fundamental set of functions in both their economic and non-economic lives. Poverty is what keeps some from achieving their full potential in these areas which can result in malnutrition,
alcohol consumption, or even sleep deprivation. They
suggest that these factors can greatly alter judgements,
preferences and decision-making and ultimately overall
productivity. Poverty is not limited to physical, external or
material components, but psychological ones as well.
Arthur Dobrin, professor at Hofstra University and
published author, has identified a direct relationship
between stress and poverty. In his article for Psychology
Today, he links the unhealthy lifestyle that poverty
produces to chronic stress and even post-traumatic stress
NBC News reported in 2018 that 56 percent of American
adults do not receive treatment for their mental illnesses.
Mental Health America found that the rate of youth with
Major Depressive Episode (MDE) increased from 11.93 to
12.63 percent. MDE is a period characterized by low mood
and other depression symptoms that lasts for two weeks
or more. According to the Anxiety and Depression
Association of America, approximately 16.1 million adults
in the United States experienced at least one major
depressive episode in 2015.
Dr. Michele Boberg wonders how many of those adults
were living below that poverty line of that year. As a
Licensed Psychologist at Associates in Behavioral
Counseling located in Muncie, Indiana, she finds it hard
to believe that those who struggle with food insecurity
and providing for their families would find it a necessity
to seek counsel. Her extensive experience in areas of
depression, trauma and abuse recovery and other personal
issues has allowed her to see a large amount of patients over the years. Although she has met with a diverse group of people, she does not believe she has met with many Muncie residents that truly reap the disadvantages of poverty.
To understand poverty in its entirety, Boberg references a book by Oscar Lewis called “The Culture of Poverty.” He looks at poverty as a culture that is defined by adaptation and reaction. Lewis says, “It represents an effort to cope with feelings of hopelessness and despair which develop from the realization of the improbability of achieving success in terms of the values and goals of the larger society.” He argues that poverty is much more than the condition in which they live in. It involves their emotional well being, state of mind and how they see themselves fitting into the rest of society.
This isn’t an experience solely attributed to adults. The Psychology Bulletin reported in 2015 that even preschool- aged children have the cognitive abilities to recognize forms of isolation. According to the article Cognitive aspects of young children’s experience of economic disadvantage, children pick up on social inequality and are aware of stereotypes related to their social class because they are able to connect these concepts to their own living situations and experiences.
Although Boberg is unsure if people of Muncie are assessing their mental health as much as they should, the city has proven that it will continue to put in effort to help those in need in other ways. Boberg says organizations such as the YWCA and Wayside Mission are geared towards women in need of food and shelter, but Muncie has resources ranging from financial assistance to career planning.
Community Resource Guide
Guide for residents in Muncie and Delaware County in need of financial assistance, career planning resources, food, shelter and more.